AA/2004/0337 - referee report (fwd)

[Boud Roukema]

Witam,


On Mon, 24 May 2004, Andrzej Marecki wrote:

> A week ago, on May 17th, Boud wrote:
>
> > i propose the Friday meeting as a decision deadline on the minor
> > corrections. If noone objects by then, then this modified version will
> > be submitted.
>
> OK, so I presume you _have_ submitted the corrected version to A&A.

Yep, done.

> Now a question: and how about astro-ph? In particular, how about...
> changing the comment there to a neutral one like: "13 pages, 18 figures, A&A
> accepted"? Our apologies surely _have_ been read by the people interested in
> receiving them and - IMVHO - there is hardly any need to keep them posted
> any longer. What do you, gals and guys, think?

Hmmm. It's true that we didn't say for what period we would have the
comment up there, and it has been there for two months, and even after
modifying it (v3), it will remain available in the future.

IMHO we should probably give this 7 days' time limit.

######################################################################
PROPOSAL: We will update the contents of the astro-ph version to be
the exact version finally accepted (well, probably it will be formally
accepted by Mon 31 May) and make the comment:

"13 pages, 18 figures, matches A&A accepted version"

DEADLINE for comments (or possibly veto): Mon 31 May 13.00g
######################################################################

pozdr
boud